How to Recover PIP Benefits When Your Insurance Company Denies Coverage

By Dodd B. Fisher Law
Women with bandaged arm filling injury claim form

Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits are designed to provide necessary financial relief after an accident, covering medical expenses, lost wages, and other related costs. However, when your insurance company denies coverage, you may feel overwhelmed and unsure about your next steps.  

At Dodd B. Fisher Law, our experienced attorneys possess the knowledge and resources to support you at every step, allowing you to focus on your recovery. Together, the firm's attorneys and staff will craft a strong case on your behalf. Schedule a free consultation today in Grosse Pointe Woods, Fort Gratiot, and surrounding areas in Michigan. 

Understanding PIP and Its Purpose

PIP insurance, also known as no-fault insurance, provides coverage for medical costs and other expenses regardless of who was at fault in an accident. While this is a mandatory requirement in many states, insurance companies can sometimes deny valid claims, leaving policyholders to unravel the complexities of insurance disputes. 

Standard Expenses Covered by PIP: 

  • Medical bills and treatment costs 

  • Rehabilitation expenses 

  • Lost wages due to the inability to work 

  • Funeral costs in the event of a fatal accident 

Before taking action against a denial, it’s essential to grasp the scope of your policy and what it should cover. 

Reasons Why PIP Claims Are Denied

If your insurance company denies your PIP claim, there’s likely a specific reason behind it. Understanding these reasons can help you develop a strong response. 

Common Reasons for Denial: 

  • Missing or incomplete documentation – Lack of necessary paperwork can delay or invalidate your claim. 

  • Exceeding coverage limits – You may have already hit the maximum payout allowed under your policy. 

  • Disputed medical necessity – The insurance company may argue that certain medical treatments were not essential. 

  • Failure to meet deadlines – Filing after the required timeline can result in a denied claim. 

  • Suspicion of fraud – Errors in documentation or perceived inconsistencies might trigger a denial. 

Insurance Bad Faith 

Insurance companies have a legal duty to handle claims fairly and in good faith. Unfortunately, there are instances where insurers engage in practices that constitute "insurance bad faith." This occurs when an insurance company acts unreasonably or dishonestly in fulfilling its obligations to policyholders.

Examples of bad faith practices include denying valid claims without justification, delaying payments unnecessarily, failing to thoroughly investigate a claim, or misrepresenting policy terms to avoid payment. If you suspect your claim was denied or mishandled due to bad faith, it is essential to advocate for your rights.  

Consulting an experienced attorney can guide you on how to hold the insurer accountable and help you secure the benefits you are owed. Remember, you deserve to be treated fairly and with respect throughout the claims process. 

Steps to Recover PIP Benefits

If your claim has been denied, it’s important to act promptly and effectively. Follow these steps to improve your chances of recovering your benefits. 

1. Review the Denial Letter 

The denial letter from your insurer will usually explain the reasons for rejecting your claim. Take the time to review it closely to understand their reasoning and spot any errors. 

2. Gather Additional Documentation 

Compile all necessary paperwork, such as accident reports, medical records, receipts, and invoices. Strong evidence plays a critical role in challenging a denial. 

3. Contact Your Insurance Company 

Contact your insurer for clarification. Sometimes, denials occur due to simple misunderstandings or missing information that can be resolved with communication. 

4. Consult an Experienced Attorney 

If your dispute remains unresolved, seeking legal guidance can be invaluable. An experienced attorney can evaluate your case, help you understand your rights, and represent you during negotiations or legal proceedings. 

5. File a Formal Appeal 

Most insurance companies have an appeal process in place. Submit a well-prepared appeal with evidence to support your case, ensuring all deadlines are met. 

6. Consider Mediation or Litigation 

If your insurer continues to be uncooperative, you may need to consider mediation or filing a lawsuit. An attorney can help guide you through these options to guarantee you receive fair treatment.

Take the First Step Toward Recovery

Undergoing an insurance denial can be challenging without proper support. At Dodd B. Fisher Law, our dedicated team will prioritize your best interests and grapple with insurance law while alleviating your stress. We can investigate your claim, negotiate with insurers, and protect your rights in court if needed. 

By staying informed, taking deliberate action, and seeking professional assistance, you can work toward recovering the benefits you’re entitled to. If you’re unsure where to begin, schedule a free consultation at Dodd B. Fisher Law. Our team serves clients across Grosse Pointe Woods, Fort Gratiot, and surrounding areas. We will gladly fight for the coverage you need during this difficult time. Call today to schedule a consultation.